metahead sat mostly untouched for years before I relaunched it this month. On paper, it came back with a decent link profile: Semrush shows 2,290 referring domains and 2,863 backlinks pointing at it. If you’re sizing up an expired or neglected domain, numbers like that look like a head start.
They mostly aren’t. When I looked at what those links actually were, fewer than a dozen sites were linking for real, and a couple of those were me. Here’s how I sorted them, what I did with the good ones, and what I’m doing about the rest.
The numbers, and why they don’t add up
The first clue is Semrush’s Authority Score, a 1 to 100 grade that combines a site’s backlinks, its organic traffic, and signs of link manipulation. As of November 13, 2026, metahead’s is 2.
Semrush’s breakdown shows why. Of the 2,290 referring domains, 2,104, about 92%, have an Authority Score of 2 or lower. Only 28 score 10 or higher.
The second clue is the history. Semrush’s records for metahead start in October 2022, years after the blog’s busiest days. Back then it counted between about 450 and 500 referring domains and gave metahead an Authority Score as high as 31. Both fell from there. The score dropped from 31 to 13 in a single month in early 2023, moved between 2 and 6 through 2024, and has been 2 since February 2025.
From mid-2024 through August 2026, Semrush counted somewhere between about 125 and 310 referring domains for metahead. On September 1, 2026, it counted 384. By October 1, it counted 2,036. The relaunch was still weeks away.
What the spike was made of
Semrush’s anchor text report, which lists the clickable words in each link, shows where it came from. 1,865 referring domains, 81% of the total, link to metahead with the same sentence: “premium backlink experts for metahead.com websites seeking higher rankings.” Semrush first saw it on September 13, 2026.
Two more variations account for another 173 domains, and both read like ads for link-building services with metahead.com dropped in. The newest referring domains Semrush has found are throwaway sites named after SEO tools and backlink checkers, mostly on .xyz, .site, and .online, each linking once.
That’s the pattern to watch for on any domain you’re evaluating:
- The same anchor text repeated across hundreds of unrelated sites.
- Anchors that read like ads, not like someone recommending a page.
- A sudden jump in referring domains that doesn’t line up with anything the site did.
- Hundreds of brand-new domains with an Authority Score of 0 to 2.
The links that were real
Strip out the spam and what’s left is small but useful. The best of it points at specific old posts, from forum threads where people shared or discussed the fix:
- A thread on Lowyat.NET, a Malaysian tech forum, links my 2010 post on Trend Micro software blocking internet connections.
- A thread on Apfeltalk, a German Apple forum, and one on a Finnish forum link my 2011 fix for uploading photos to Facebook from an iPhone.
- A thread on DNTrade, an Australian domain forum, links my 2010 post on pushing a GoDaddy domain to another account.
The rest are a mixed bag: link pages on archived GeoCities (gosh, even more memories. Google it.) and FortuneCity sites, a web directory page, and a couple of old comments and a forum profile that are most likely mine. Several are nofollow, which tells Google the linking site would rather not be associated with the page it links to, or have Google crawl it through that link. My own comments don’t count for much, but the forum threads are real people pointing at real pages.
What I did with them
The forum links are part of the reason those posts came back. The other part is that old posts carry memories, as I wrote in the relaunch post. When I restored metahead’s 2008 to 2014 posts, I rewrote the Trend Micro, Facebook, and GoDaddy posts, plus a Commission Junction password post, so a reader following one of those old links lands on something that still works.
The old addresses mattered, too. Semrush’s list of linked metahead pages included about 115 old posts and archive pages, mostly at the /blog/year/month/day/ addresses the new site doesn’t use. Redirects now send the old post addresses to the current posts, and I wrote up how in my post on redirecting old URLs after a relaunch.
Two of the forum links needed their own fix. The addresses inside those two links were cut short, to things like /how-to-push-…dy-domain-name, so they led nowhere. I added redirects for both, so they now land on the right posts.
The posts I couldn’t make useful again, mostly expired coupon and deal posts, return a 410 instead.
What I’m not doing about the spam
I’m not disavowing it. Google’s disavow tool lets you ask Google to ignore links to your site, but Google says most sites won’t need it. It says to disavow only if you have a considerable number of spammy, artificial, or low-quality links, and they’ve caused, or likely will cause, a manual action against your site.
I’ve never bought links, I didn’t build these, and Search Console shows no manual action on metahead. Contacting 1,865 automated sites to ask for removals isn’t realistic, so I’m leaving them alone and watching Search Console.
Has it helped?
It’s too early to say. As of November 13, Google has indexed the GoDaddy post. It has found the Facebook post but hasn’t indexed it yet, and it doesn’t know about the Trend Micro post at all. I’m submitting them in Search Console over the next few days, and I’ll report back.
What I’d tell anyone buying an old domain
If you’re judging an expired or neglected domain by its backlinks, here’s what metahead taught me:
- Ignore the headline count. Check the anchor text report and the referring domain history first.
- Look for the handful of links from real pages, like forum threads, articles, and resource pages, and note which old URLs they point to.
- If you can bring those pages back in a useful form, do it, and redirect the old addresses to them.
- Don’t panic about spam you didn’t create. Google says most sites won’t need to disavow.
I’m fairly sure metahead had far more links in its active years than Semrush can show, and that many of the sites behind them simply aren’t around anymore. Of the 2,290 linking domains Semrush counts today, I found fewer than a dozen real links when I went through them. The rest is noise. Those few are still the most useful thing the old domain brought with it.
Top photo: Mutebi Ivan Junior (CC0).

