An honest look at new gTLDs

New gTLDs now hold 52.9 million domains, but most don't get renewed. A domain investor's honest look at what they get right, where they fall short, and when one makes sense.

Published Nov 21, 2026 · 4 min read

Since ICANN opened applications in 2012, more than 1,200 new domain extensions have been added: .shop, .online, .xyz, .app, and many more. A new round is on the way. My own portfolio is mostly .com, and I think .com will always be king, so keep that bias in mind. But new gTLDs aren’t going away, and here’s my honest take on where they stand.

How big new gTLDs have become

Bigger than most people think. At the end of June 2026, new gTLDs held 52.9 million registrations, up 34% in a year, according to the Domain Name Industry Brief. That’s about 13% of all domains. For comparison, .com alone had 166.6 million.

More are coming. ICANN’s 2026 application window closed in August, and about 1,600 applications are going ahead. About a fifth of them, 333, are brand applications that only one company would use. Many of the rest are for extensions that would be open to the public.

I covered .ai and .io, which are country codes rather than new gTLDs, in my post on what startups are picking. This post is about the rest.

What new gTLDs get right

The biggest plus is availability. The short, clean name you want is almost certainly taken in .com, but there’s a good chance it’s free in a new extension. Some extensions also say something useful about what’s on the site, like a store on .shop.

Search isn’t a problem, either. Google said in 2015 that its systems treat new gTLDs like other gTLDs, and that keywords in the extension don’t give you any advantage or disadvantage.

Where new gTLDs fall short

This is the part the registration pages don’t mention:

  • Most of them don’t get renewed. New gTLDs as a group renew at about 31%, according to Dynadot’s figures, while .com and .net renew at about 75%, according to the Domain Name Industry Brief. Most aren’t renewed when they come up, and many are dropped after a cheap first year.
  • The registry controls the price. Under ICANN’s standard agreement, a new gTLD registry generally only has to give registrars 180 days’ notice before raising renewal prices. It can’t single out your name for a higher renewal price unless you agreed to that price when you registered, as with premium names, and the registry has to let registrars renew names for up to 10 years at the old price before an increase kicks in, but there’s no cap on how much it can go up. .com price increases, by contrast, are capped by Verisign’s agreements at 7% a year, in four of every six years.
  • Premium names can cost a premium every year. Registries flag many short and popular names as premium. Depending on the registry, a premium name’s renewal can cost as much as the registration, as DNSimple explains. Check the renewal price, not just the first-year price.
  • A spammy reputation. Cheap new gTLDs are popular with scammers: Interisle found that new gTLDs with very low registration fees generally attract phishing. Interisle found that new gTLDs hold just 12% of the market but accounted for nearly half of all cybercrime domains reported. I saw the same pattern in the spam links pointing at metahead, where about 80% of the linking sites, mostly spam, used new gTLDs like .shop, .store, .online, and .xyz.
  • They’re hard to resell. A weak extension is one of the red flags that make me pass on a domain. The low renewal rate suggests many owners decide their name isn’t worth keeping.

When a new gTLD makes sense

I’m not saying never. A new gTLD can be the right call if you’re building something, not buying to resell, and the extension completes the name in a way people will remember, the way Alphabet uses abc.xyz and Cash App uses cash.app. If you go that route:

  • Check the renewal price before you buy, and avoid names with premium renewals unless the name is worth that every year.
  • Consider registering for several years up front, so a price increase can’t catch you by surprise.
  • Look at the extension’s reputation. If it’s full of spam, some of that can rub off on you.
  • Register the .com too if you can afford it, so the visitors and emails that go there by habit end up with you.

As investments, I mostly pass on new gTLDs. As places to build, a few of them are fine, as long as you know the trade-offs going in.

Top photo: Jennifer Bourn (CC0).

Published Nov 21, 2026 · Written by J. Newman

Next post.com vs .ai vs .io: what startups are actually picking

Comments