I look at a lot of domain names, in auctions, in expiring lists, and in offers people send me. I pass on most of them within seconds. That isn’t because I’ve studied each one closely. It’s because a few red flags tell me everything I need to know before I spend any more time on it.
Name quality comes first
Everything starts with the name itself. Is it a word or phrase people actually use? Is it easy to say, spell, and remember? Would a business want to put it on a sign?
If the answer is no, I stop there. I won’t spend time checking trademarks, backlinks, or who might buy it if the name isn’t sellable in the first place. The red flags below come after that first test.
The red flags that make me pass
Any one of these is usually enough:
- A trademark in the name, especially a famous mark or brand. If it contains a brand someone else owns, realistically the only buyer is the brand, and the brand can file a complaint instead of paying you. I once registered a keyword domain with “Google” in it, and the next morning I had a cease and desist letter on Google’s behalf. Under the UDRP, a trademark owner can get a domain transferred or cancelled if it shows the name is identical or confusingly similar to its mark, that you have no rights or legitimate interests in it, and that it was registered and used in bad faith.
- Hyphens or numbers. People forget the hyphen, and they don’t know whether to type the number or spell it out. Either way, some of the traffic goes somewhere else.
- Awkward spelling. If I have to spell it out when I say it, it fails. A name should survive being said once over the phone.
- Too long. Every extra word makes it harder to remember and less likely anyone will pay much for it.
- A weak extension. Plenty of extensions are fine to build on, but new gTLDs get dropped far more often than .com: as a group, they renew at about 31%, compared with about 75% for .com and .net, according to Dynadot’s figures.
- A spammy past. I check what the domain was used for on the Wayback Machine. If it hosted spam or picked up a search penalty, that history can follow it. I wrote about what old backlinks can look like in my metahead case study.
- The price to acquire it. A good name at the wrong price is still a pass. If I can’t see a realistic resale price comfortably above what I’d pay, plus the years of renewals while I wait, I walk away.
The red flag that’s easy to miss
This one isn’t about the name. It’s about the auction. If a domain looks like a great buy and nobody else is bidding on it, or the other bidders drop out early, there’s usually a reason. I’ve been caught out by this twice.
The first time, I was bidding on what I thought was a premium jewelry keyword. Someone else was bidding on it as well, and at some point they stopped. I was pretty happy. It was days later that I noticed the name was spelled “jewerly,” not “jewelry.”
The second time, I can’t remember the exact name anymore, but it went like this: I thought I was bidding on alcapone.com. The seller was being tricky. They had written the name as aIcapone.com, with a capital I where you’d expect a lowercase L. In many fonts, especially sans-serif ones, the two look almost the same. The domain was really aicapone.com.
Both times, I saw the name I wanted to see. Now, when a name seems too good to be ignored by everyone else, I slow down and check the spelling letter by letter.
How I check a name quickly
My order is simple, and it’s built so I can stop early:
| Step | What I do | What it catches |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Say it and type it | Read it out loud, then type it myself in lowercase, from scratch | Misspellings and look-alike letters |
| 2. Judge the name | Is it a real term, and would a business want it? | Whether it’s sellable at all |
| 3. Trademarks | Check for existing marks | A brand that could file a complaint |
| 4. History | Look at its past use and backlinks | Spam or a penalty from a past owner |
| 5. Price | Decide what I’d pay | A number I’ll stick to |
Most names never make it past the first two steps, and that’s the point. The time I save on names I pass on is time I can spend on the few that are actually worth it.
Top photo: Nilo Velez (CC0).